Report ·

Where should a maker sell online? Etsy vs Shopify vs Ko-fi vs Big Cartel vs Bernard

A woodcut of a market stall under a striped awning, four patterned pots on the counter beneath a hanging tag, and a fifth pot standing apart on a wooden crate beside a small shop bell.

The short answer: Etsy brings you buyers, and takes a slice of every order for it, with the buyer staying Etsy’s customer. Shopify gives you a serious shop of your own, but it is a shop first and a website second, and the bill grows with apps and card fees. Ko-fi and Big Cartel are cheap and honest, and both are a page or a shop rather than a website that tells your story and keeps your mailing list. Bernard gives you both halves: a website of your own with the shop built in, 0% on every sale, your buyers on your own contact list, your name written into your work, and someone reading the numbers and looking after it. £200 a year for the site with the shop included, one flat price.

Five places a maker, illustrator, potter, photographer or small shop can sell online, and five very different deals.

Etsy is a marketplace: a crowd of buyers already there, and a fee on every order for standing in front of them. Shopify is a shop you own, built for retail. Ko-fi is a page where fans tip you, join a membership and buy from a small shop. Big Cartel is a plain, flat-priced shop made for artists. Bernard builds you a website with the shop in it, and keeps working on it after launch.

This scorecard compares the jobs, not the size of the companies. If you are weighing up website builders rather than places to sell, the sister page is Squarespace vs WordPress vs Wix vs Bernard. A WooCommerce shop is a WordPress site with a shop plugin, so it belongs with WordPress there; what a WooCommerce shop really costs has its numbers.

Bernard is an AI-assisted website and marketing platform for small businesses. He builds a new site or moves an existing one, keeps it fast and readable to search and AI tools, and looks after it. Once measuring is on, he reads your numbers each week and suggests what to do next, with a button that does it. On the Medium and Large plans he also plans your marketing every six weeks and drafts your posts, emails and pages. Everything lands on a draft you approve. One flat price per site.

How the scoring works

The scores are for an independent maker, artist or small shop in the UK who sells their own work. Five means the platform does that job particularly well for that seller. One means the seller will need another tool, more technical knowledge or paid help.

They are editorial judgements. Every 1/5, 2/5 and 5/5 carries a short reason in the table, except where a platform’s own pages say nothing about the job, which scores 3/5 rather than a guess. The middle scores mean capable, with a qualification explained in the surrounding section.

There is no grand total. A potter selling at fairs cares about being found and about postage. An illustrator selling prints and taking commissions cares about who keeps the buyer and what happens to their pictures. Weighting those equally would give a tidy number and a poor decision.

Prices were read from each company’s own pricing page on 12 November 2026 (Etsy’s fee policy on 15 October 2026). Ko-fi and Big Cartel show their prices in US dollars, so they are given in dollars here rather than converted.

These are comparisons of broadly similar business needs, not identical products. Some of these services include things Bernard does not do. Bernard includes planning, reading your numbers and doing the work, which these combinations do not give you without more tools or more of your own time.

Setting up and selling

CapabilityBernardEtsyShopifyKo-fiBig Cartel
Easy to get started5/5 - built for you from a short interview, or your listings brought across5/5 - list and sell the same day4/55/5 - a page in minutes4/5
Buyers who have never heard of you3/55/5 - a marketplace full of people searching2/5 - you bring every visitor2/5 - built for fans you already have2/5 - you bring every visitor
Your own web address5/5 - your domain, your pages1/5 - a shop on etsy.com, a site costs 15 USD a month extra5/5 - your domain2/5 - a page at ko-fi.com4/5
A website around the shop5/5 - pages, blog, forms and the shop are one site1/5 - a shop front only3/52/5 - a profile page with posts and a gallery2/5 - shop pages, little else
Physical and digital products5/5 - downloads with their own limits and licence note4/55/5 - both, deeply4/54/5
Sizes, colours and stock4/54/55/5 - built for inventory2/5 - a simple shop3/5
Paying per listing5/5 - no listing fee2/5 - 0.20 USD per listing, renewed every four months5/5 - no listing fee5/5 - no listing fee3/5
Bring an existing shop across5/5 - Shopify and Squarespace shops read from the live store, Etsy listings brought across for you2/5 - listed by hand3/51/5 - by hand4/5
Enquire rather than buy5/5 - keep the price on show, take the conversation by email2/5 - messages, no enquire-only listing3/55/5 - commissions are a built-in job2/5

Etsy earns its 5/5 for being found. Nothing else on this page puts a small maker in front of strangers who are already looking for exactly that kind of thing, and that is what its fees buy. Its weakness is the mirror image: the shop is Etsy’s, the address is Etsy’s, and a website of your own is an extra 15 USD a month through Pattern.

Newer marketplaces are forming around the AI question. Fybe (fybe.art), which began its public push in October 2026 as a marketplace for human-made work with generative AI banned and no paid ads, is the one makers on Threads are opening shops on. It is the same trade as Etsy, their address, their rules and a fee on every sale (5% on its free plan, plus Stripe’s card fee), with far fewer buyers for now, and at the time of writing it cannot ship physical goods to the EU, EEA or Northern Ireland. Sell there if its crowd suits you, and keep a place of your own beside it.

Shopify is the strongest shop in the row. Variants, stock, fulfilment and a vast app store make it the right home when the shop is the business. The website around the shop is where it thins: pages about who you are, a blog that gets found, forms and bookings all exist, but they are built around the till.

Ko-fi and Big Cartel are honest about what they are. Ko-fi’s page is a place to be supported, and its commissions tool is the best answer here for an illustrator who takes custom work. Big Cartel is a shop of its own on your own domain, with a free plan to start and up to 50 products on Platinum or 500 on Diamond, from its own pages. Neither is a website with the rest of your business on it.

Bernard scores 3/5 for being found because he is not a marketplace. What he does is make the site easy for Google and the AI assistants to read and quote, and show you each month which AI companies came and what they came for. That is slower than Etsy’s crowd and it is yours.

What a sale actually costs

The plan price is the number on the advert. The fee per sale is the number that grows with your success. Take a £40 item with £4 postage, sold to a buyer in the UK, so the order is £44.

On a £44 orderBernardEtsyShopify BasicKo-fiBig Cartel Platinum
The plan, a year£200 for the site, shop includednone£228 paid yearly, £300 paid monthlyfree, or $12 a month for Gold$15 a month
Platform fee on the sale0%6.5% transaction fee, £2.86none with Shopify Payments, 2% through another provider5% on the free plan, £2.20; 0% on Gold0%
Listing feenone0.20 USD, renewed every four monthsnonenonenone
Card processingStripe’s own rate, 1.5% + 20p, £0.864% + £0.20, £1.96, plus a 0.48% regulatory fee, £0.212% + 25p, £1.13Stripe’s or PayPal’s own rate; via Stripe £0.86Stripe’s or PayPal’s own rate; via Stripe £0.86
Taken from this orderabout £0.86about £5.03, or £11.63 if the buyer came through an Offsite Adabout £1.13about £3.06, or £0.86 on Goldabout £0.86
Who holds the moneyyou, in your own Stripe accountEtsy pays out to youShopify Payments pays out to youyou, in your own PayPal or Stripe accountyou, in your own PayPal or Stripe account

Etsy’s Offsite Ads deserve their own line. Etsy advertises listings elsewhere, and when a sale comes through one of those ads it charges 15% of the order. You can opt out while your shop is small. Once a shop has sold 10,000 USD in a year the fee falls to 12% and taking part becomes compulsory for the life of the shop. Every Etsy fee, with the worked example, has the full list.

Over a year the picture flips with volume. A shop that sells a little pays Etsy less than any yearly plan, and Etsy is the cheaper place to sell. A shop selling 150 orders like the one above pays Etsy about £755 in fees, plus 150 listing fees and any Offsite Ads, against Shopify’s £228 plan and about £170 in card fees, Bernard’s £200 and about £129 in Stripe fees, or Big Cartel’s $180 and the same Stripe fees. Big Cartel comes out cheapest on the shop alone, with Bernard next, below Shopify. What the Bernard figure buys that the others do not is in the next three sections: the website around the shop, the buyer kept as your customer, your name on your work, and somebody looking after all of it.

Two notes on tax. Etsy states its fees before VAT and says UK sellers may be charged VAT on them. Shopify’s UK pricing page does not say whether its prices include VAT. Bernard is not VAT-registered, so the number shown is the number paid.

Who keeps the buyer

After the saleBernardEtsyShopifyKo-fiBig Cartel
The buyer is your customer5/5 - every buyer becomes a contact on your own list1/5 - the buyer is Etsy’s, and your competitors are a scroll away5/5 - your customer record4/54/5
Email them later5/5 - campaigns and journeys come with the site1/5 - the buyer’s details are Etsy’s, under Etsy’s rules4/53/52/5 - another service
Reviews and history travel with you5/5 - your site, your pages1/5 - reviews and sales history stay with the Etsy shop4/53/53/5
The shop’s address is yours5/5 - your domain1/5 - etsy.com/shop/yourname5/5 - your domain2/5 - ko-fi.com/yourname4/5
Leaving later5/5 - plain files, a full export, your domain in your name2/5 - your reviews, sales history and favourites stay behind4/53/54/5

This is the row Etsy sellers feel most and talk about least. A buyer who loved what you made searches Etsy for it next time, where your competitors are one scroll away, and Etsy’s own rules decide how you may write to them. On a site of your own, a buyer is a person with a name and an email address who said yes to you once and can be asked again.

Bernard’s advantage is the join. The buyer, the person who filled in your contact form and the one who signed up for your newsletter are one contact, not three records in three tools. The email campaigns and the automated sequences come with the site rather than as a separate subscription. The platform is yours to leave: a Bernard site is plain files, there is always a full export, and your web address is registered in your own name.

Protecting your workBernardEtsyShopifyKo-fiBig Cartel
Your rules, not a marketplace licence5/5 - your own site, no marketplace terms over your photos1/5 - from 16 December 2026 Etsy and its partners may train AI on listing photos and descriptions4/53/54/5
A written “no” to AI training inside each picture file5/5 - while the Protect your work switch is on, the file says it is not for AI training1/5 - the listing licence runs the other way3/53/53/5
Your name and copyright written into the file5/5 - for every photo you mark as yours3/53/53/53/5
Hidden location and camera data removed5/5 - stripped from every new upload before it goes on the site3/53/53/53/5
Proof you had the picture first5/5 - untouched original kept, with a fingerprint and the date it arrived3/53/53/53/5
See which AI companies read your pages5/5 - a monthly report, per AI company, by what they came for2/5 - Etsy’s stats cover the shop, not AI readers3/53/53/5

Where a platform’s own pages say nothing about a job, it scores 3/5 here rather than a guess either way. We have not read Shopify’s, Ko-fi’s or Big Cartel’s terms for this page; the Etsy scores rest on Etsy’s published terms.

Etsy published new terms on 26 October 2026 that take effect on 16 December 2026. One change matters to anyone who sells their own work there: Etsy and its partners may use listing photos and descriptions to train AI. What Etsy’s own words say goes through the terms line by line. For the wider question of what a marketplace, Instagram or Meta may do with a picture once you post it, read who sets the rules for your photos.

No website can stop a copy being made, and this page will not pretend otherwise. What a site of your own changes is who sets the rules. On Bernard, every new upload has its hidden location and device data removed before it goes on your site, so a visitor cannot read where your studio is from your picture. When you say a photo is yours, Bernard writes your name and copyright line into the file itself, in the fields cameras, editors and search engines read, and while the Protect your work switch is on the file also says it is not for AI training. He keeps your untouched original, with a fingerprint and the date it arrived, as proof you had it first. And the AI traffic report shows which AI companies read your pages and what they came for. None of that stops a determined person. It makes your position clear and your claim easier to prove.

The honest comparison is between a marketplace’s licence, which you accept to sell there, and your own site, where no marketplace licence applies.

What happens after launch

Ongoing jobBernardEtsyShopifyKo-fiBig Cartel
Hosting, updates and security done for you5/5 - fully managed, no plugins to update5/5 - Etsy runs the marketplace5/5 - Shopify runs the platform5/5 - Ko-fi runs the page5/5 - Big Cartel runs the shop
Backups and an earlier version to go back to5/5 - a year of versions kept3/53/53/53/5
Someone reads your numbers and says what to do5/5 - a weekly note, up to three suggestions, each with a button that does it2/5 - stats, no advice3/52/5 - supporter counts2/5 - sales and traffic figures
Broken links, speed and accessibility checked5/5 - re-checked on every publish, accessibility weekly2/5 - not your pages to check3/52/5 - not your pages to check3/5
Your marketing planned and drafted5/5 - every six weeks on Medium and Large, with posts, emails and pages drafted for approval1/5 - Etsy Ads and Offsite Ads, paid per click or per sale3/51/5 - left to you1/5 - left to you
Shop tidying noticed4/53/53/52/52/5
Improvement, not just upkeep5/5 - suggestions keep arriving, you approve each one2/5 - the marketplace improves, your shop is yours to improve2/5 - apps and agencies2/5 - the page is what it is2/5 - the shop is what it is

Every platform in this row keeps its own machine running; none of them leaves you patching software. The difference is what happens to your shop. Etsy, Shopify, Ko-fi and Big Cartel give you figures. Bernard reads them each week and tells you the one or two things worth doing, with a button that does it, and nothing reaches your visitors until you approve. On the Medium and Large plans he plans the marketing every six weeks and drafts the posts, emails and pages that carry it out.

Shop tidying is a 4/5 for Bernard rather than a 5/5 because it is still a suggestion. He notices a sold-out product that is still on sale, or a product photo with no description, and lists it with the evidence. He does not hide, rewrite or reorder anything in your shop on his own, and he never touches a price, a discount or a refund. That stays yours.

Features you may never need

Bernard has no marketplace crowd, no tipping jar, no print-on-demand app store and no multi-warehouse stock machinery. Those are real limits. An illustrator who lives on commissions and tips may be happiest on Ko-fi. A shop with real volume, fulfilment and wholesale belongs on Shopify. A maker who only wants a flat-priced shop and nothing else is well served by Big Cartel.

Ask whether a missing item would change the day-to-day running of your business. The longest feature list rarely answers that.

Who should choose each one

Choose Etsy for being found, and go in knowing that every order pays for it and the buyer stays Etsy’s. Most makers should keep it, and add a place of their own beside it.

Choose Shopify when the shop is the business: stock, volume, fulfilment, perhaps staff. Its tools earn the bill.

Choose Ko-fi when your income is tips, memberships and commissions from people who already follow you, and a shop is a side door.

Choose Big Cartel when you want a plain, flat-priced shop on your own address with nothing taken per sale, and you are happy to do the rest elsewhere.

Choose Bernard when you want the website and the shop to be one thing, on your own address, with 0% on every sale, your buyers on your own list, your name written into your work, and someone reading the numbers and looking after the lot. £200 a year for the site, with the shop included. Courses, memberships and a second site can be switched on beside it.

See what Bernard would do with your business. Already have a website? Paste its address and he measures it up, free, and shows you the new place before you decide anything. Starting from nothing, or from an Etsy shop? Tell him what you are building.

Questions people ask

Should I sell on Etsy or on my own website?
Both, for most makers. Etsy brings buyers who have never heard of you, and charges for it on every order. A site of your own costs a flat amount, takes nothing per sale on Bernard, Big Cartel or Ko-fi Gold, and keeps the buyer as your customer rather than Etsy’s. The sellers who do best keep Etsy for being found and send the people who come back to a shop of their own.
What does Etsy take from a sale in the UK?
On a £40 item with £4 postage sold to a UK buyer, Etsy’s transaction fee (6.5%), payment processing (4% plus £0.20) and regulatory operating fee (0.48%) come to about £5.03, which is 11.4% of the order, before the 0.20 USD listing fee and before any Offsite Ads fee of 15%. All from Etsy’s own fee policy, read 15 October 2026.
Is Shopify worth it for a small maker?
If the shop is the business, with stock, volume and fulfilment, Shopify’s tools earn its bill: Basic is £228 a year paid yearly, with 2% plus 25p on every online card payment. If the shop is one part of a business that also needs a website, a mailing list and someone to look after it, you are paying a shop-first platform’s prices for a website with a till in it.
What is the difference between Ko-fi and Big Cartel?
Ko-fi is a page where fans tip you, join a membership, commission you or buy from a small shop. It is free with a 5% service fee on sales, or $12 a month for 0%, and payments land in your own PayPal or Stripe account. Big Cartel is a shop of its own, on your own web address from $15 a month for up to 50 products, with no fee per sale. Neither is a full website with pages about your work, a blog or a mailing list.
Does Bernard take a cut of what I sell?
No. A Bernard site with a shop is £200 a year, flat, with the shop included in every size, and Bernard takes 0% of every sale. Buyers pay through your own Stripe account at Stripe’s own card rate, 1.5% plus 20p for a standard UK card online. Every buyer becomes a contact on your own list.
Can I stop Etsy training AI on my listings?
Etsy’s terms, published 26 October 2026 and in force from 16 December 2026, say Etsy and its partners may use listing photos and descriptions to train AI. On a website of your own, no marketplace licence applies. Bernard strips hidden location data from new uploads, writes your name and copyright into photos you mark as yours, and keeps an untouched original as proof. No website can promise that every AI company listens.

You might also want to read

Built with BernardCookie settings